Keep More Of Your Gain: How DSTs Help Real Estate Investors Defer Taxes and Build Wealth
Show summary
In this episode, Ray Johnson shares his extensive expertise on real estate investment strategies, tax deferral techniques like DSTs, and the critical liability risks real estate professionals often underestimate. Gain insights into advanced investment tools and how to protect your assets effectively.
Key takeaways
- Depreciation recapture can create a massive taxable gain: Ray's example fourplex went from $140,000 (with $100,000 depreciated on the building, $40,000 land basis) to $1 million in value, creating a $960,000 taxable gain and roughly a $250,000 tax bill at sale.
- Only an estimated 11% of real estate professionals, accountants, and lawyers surveyed in one study had ever heard of a DST, including a commercial real estate broker with 16 years of experience Ray spoke with on a prior podcast.
- DSTs are IRS-approved under Section 1031, operate in all 50 states, and as of 2024 there were roughly 50 active DST sponsors nationwide managing an estimated $80 billion in assets.
- A straight 1031 exchange requires like-kind property, a 45-day identification window, and a 180-day closing period; DSTs satisfy 1031 requirements without the pressure of personally finding and closing on replacement property.
- DST investors get fractional ownership in pre-packaged, debt-already-in-place assets (apartments, medical offices, distribution centers, government buildings, producing oil wells) without personal liability on the loan, typically receiving distributions in the 5-6% range (about $5,000/month on a $1 million stake in Ray's example).
- DSTs are illiquid with no public market, though Ray notes he has received and could accept offers to sell his interests privately; investors also give up decision-making control to the sponsor.
- Holding an investment until death allows heirs to receive a stepped-up basis, which is the one way to eliminate the deferred tax rather than just postpone it.
- The biggest liability risk Ray identifies for real estate professionals is failing to advise clients about DST options, since a client who later learns he could have saved $250,000 may hold the agent responsible.
In this episode
- 00:00Cold open: the liability of not advising clients about DSTs
- 01:59Introduction to Ray Johnson
- 03:14Ray's path from a $140,000 fourplex to real estate investing
- 09:00The tax problem: depreciation and a $960,000 taxable gain
- 10:00Discovering the 1031 exchange and its limits
- 12:00What a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) is and how it works
- 16:00Example: $1M rolled into a DST, sponsor aggregation, 5-year flip math
- 18:301031 exchange rules vs. DST flexibility (45-day ID, 180-day close)
- 21:00Biggest liability risk: failing to advise clients on DSTs
- 22:54Evaluating E&O insurance policies and coverage gaps
About the guest
Ray Johnson is a senior officer at a major insurance company (now retired), a published author, and an expert witness and litigator who has worked a landmark $152 million plaintiff's judgment. He began investing in real estate with a fourplex purchased for $140,000, went on to own multiple real estate ventures, and has owned Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs) himself for years, including interests in producing oil wells. He has also written books, available on Amazon under the name Raymond B. Johnson, and has done expert witness work on insurance coverage issues for 20-30 years.
Listen to the audio
“Not advising your client about a DST... if he later finds out he could have saved 250,000 bucks, he's going to look at you and say, why didn't you help me in this transaction?”
Ray
“You can't offer something you don't know anything about.”
Ray
“In life people make money, but money makes money. So you got to keep the money making money when you sleep at night. Otherwise you have to have a job.”
Ray
“Insurance is, you don't buy it because you've liked it in that sense, you buy it because you can't afford not to have it.”
Ray
Questions answered in this episode
What is a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST)?
A DST is an IRS-approved legal entity, originally created under Delaware law, that lets investors roll 1031 exchange proceeds into a trust where other investors' money is aggregated to buy institutional-quality real estate (apartments, medical offices, distribution centers, government buildings, even producing oil wells). Investors get fractional ownership, are not personally liable on the debt, and receive regular distributions, but they give up management control and the investment is illiquid.
How does a DST defer taxes compared to a regular sale?
Ray gives an example of a fourplex bought for $140,000 that appreciated to $1 million, with only $40,000 of basis left after depreciation, creating a $960,000 taxable gain and roughly a $250,000 tax bill at sale. Instead of paying that tax, the proceeds can roll into a DST (a form of 1031 exchange) to defer the tax, keeping the full amount working and earning returns.
What are the rules and deadlines for a 1031 exchange, and how does a DST compare?
A straight 1031 exchange requires like-kind property, a 45-day identification period, and a 180-day closing period, plus the hassle of actively managing a newly purchased property. A DST satisfies 1031 requirements but is a pre-packaged, professionally managed offering, so investors avoid hunting for replacement property and avoid going back into active management.
What returns and structure can investors expect from a DST?
In Ray's example, $30 million from 30 investors is pooled to buy a $60 million property (50% LTV). Investors might receive around 5-6% annual distributions (about $5,000/month on a $1 million investment), and if the property is flipped after five years at a gain (e.g., sold for $70 million with the loan paid down), the gain is shared back to investors, who can then roll it into another DST or cash out and pay tax on it.
What happens to taxes on a DST investment if the owner dies?
Ray notes that if you hold the investment until death, your heirs receive a stepped-up basis, which is the one way to avoid paying the deferred tax altogether rather than just deferring it further.
What is the biggest liability risk for real estate agents and professionals regarding DSTs?
According to Ray, the biggest risk is not advising clients about DST options. If a client later learns they could have saved $250,000 in taxes by using a DST, they will question why the professional didn't inform them, creating a liability exposure. Ray stresses that professionals can't offer something they don't know about, so education on these tools is essential.
Resources and links
- Ray Johnson’s Website
- Ray Johnson on Amazon
- Ray Johnson’s Email Address: raymondbjohnson@gmail.com
Full transcript
Ray (00:00)
Not advising your client about a DST. The reason is, is because if you’re a somehow assisting him somehow in the transaction and he later finds out he could have saved 250,000 bucks, he’s going to look at you and say, why didn’t you help me in this transaction? And so people need to be educated on that because you know, you can’t offer something you don’t know anything about
Scott Bursey (01:59)
Welcome back to the real estate pros podcast.
The podcast dedicated to giving you the cutting edge insights you need to dominate your market. I’m your host, Scott Bursey. And today we are deep diving into risk liability and the crucial role insurance plays in protecting your real estate career. Joining us is a true heavyweight in the legal insurance fields. Ray Johnson. Ray is a senior officer at a major insurance company, a published author and a highly sought after legal expert.
and a witness and a litigator whose career includes a landmark. 152 million Plains of Judgment. Ray, thank you for being here.
Ray (02:44)
My pleasure. Happy to visit with anybody about these things because they’ve always been interesting to me. What can I tell you about?
Scott Bursey (02:53)
This is an honor having you here. And before we dive into the how, I want to talk about the who. For those just meeting you, tell us about the path that led you to real estate and the core vision that drives your work today,
Ray (03:14)
Well, I heard early on when I was younger that they just should invest in land because they don’t make it anymore. And so it always ⁓ rises up in value. so when I got a little bit of chunky money, when I started working, I put it down on a fourplex and ⁓ learned the trials of, ⁓
you know, being a landlord on that sort of thing. And ⁓ it was an education, but in addition to that, it made some money. And that seemed to work out well. So then I got further involved in other real estate transactions. And then…
You said I was a senior official at the insurance company and that’s true. It’s in the past 10th cent since because I retired. And when I ⁓ retired from there, I was sort of ⁓ wanting to do other things besides manage real estate and, you know, fix toilets or hire managers or whatever was required to take care of that. So, in.
selling real estate, I realized there was going to be a big tax problem. And I’ll give you an example. It doesn’t necessarily be totally what I occurred because I had a large number of real estate ventures. But my first one was a fourplex that I purchased for $140,000. And let’s just assume that 20 years later, it was worth a million.
And, uh, as you know, from the accounting side of things, you get to depreciate the building out, but not the land. And so I attributed the land to the $40,000 and depreciated out the a hundred thousand dollars over the next few years against taxes. And so when it came time to sell the property, let’s say it was worth a million dollars. The only basis in the property was the land of 40,000 bucks. That meant when I sold it.
I would have a $960,000 taxable gain.
That was disturbing to me to realize that I was going to lose maybe a quarter of the investment to taxes. So I explored what could I do because in life people make money, but money makes money. So you got to keep the money making money when you sleep at night. Otherwise you have to have a job. And so, ⁓
I learned about the 1031 exchange option, is the section of the IRS code, which allows for these kinds of transactions to roll over and defer taxes. There’s only one way, and I’ll ⁓ address that later, how to avoid the tax on that. And it’s not a pleasant way, but you roll the money over, which means when you sell the property for
million dollars now you have to go buy another piece of property worth more which puts you into a higher bracket yet eventually potentially and so what I did was I didn’t want to do apartments anymore really and I still wanted my money and so I searched around and found a
IRS approved device called the Delaware Statutory Trust. And over the years that I’ve owned Delaware Statutory Trust, commonly called DSTs, I learned real estate professionals, accountants, lawyers, commercial people. In fact, one study showed that only 11 % of them have ever heard of a DST.
And, the advantages of it. And in my years of owning them, I’ve talked to a lot of people who should know. fact, I did a previous podcast with somebody that was a commercial real estate ⁓ broker. And he didn’t know about it. And he had been doing that for 16 years, if I recall correctly. So it comes down to what is a DST.
Well, it’s a legal entity that’s created initially under the laws of the state of Delaware called a statutory trust. And it’s been operative for some 25, 30 years. ⁓ So the IRS approves it. And essentially what it is is in your money rolls over not to another.
Piece of property that you own outright, but it rolls over into a trust where other people aggregate their money together. And so there are some real advantages and disadvantages of doing things that way, which I will cover. ⁓ DSTs are functional in all 50 states. And ⁓ while Delaware may have been the one that initiated it, other states
have also come up with their own statutory scheme. And so it’s approved. It’s not some slide around the corner device of avoiding taxes.
And in fact, ⁓ it defers taxes because someday, you know, all that’s going to get liquidated. And I will address that you may pay taxes on it if you take it at that point in time. And it may be a bigger amount because, you know, ⁓
The government always seems to win on taxes with one exception. And that is if you own it and die, kind of an unpleasant thing about ownership. If you die, your heirs get a stepped up basis. Now, most people will understand that. can cover it if it’s not clear. So it all comes down to the government approves this scheme and, ⁓
The essence of it is that you keep more of your money working under the theory that money makes money than if you pay the taxes and lose that amount of money. And so ⁓ I listed for myself ⁓ some of these things. In fact, I’ve written a book about this that I’ll publish. because it’s, but it’s all over the internet. You don’t need my book. You know, just get in and do the research there. It’s a…
tax-deferred strategy, it’s because when people sell real estate, they’re probably gonna face one of the highest tax bills they’ll ever see. For example, I was saying if that $140,000 piece of property inflated to a million dollars in 10, 15 years, then I was gonna face a
$160,000 tax occurrence, which would be in say a 25 % range, somewhere around 250,000 bucks that you lose the taxes right up front. So the other thing that’s great about a DST, and maybe I should describe what happens to the million dollars.
You find a sponsor and they’re all over. These are all financial people and ⁓ people, you know, like to have a little bit of the money spill their way when it passes through their hands, which is fair. ⁓ But ⁓ DST is approved in all 50 states. It’s a federal law ⁓ that’s governed by state property law. And ⁓ Delaware started it, but
many, many States have them and there are many so-called sponsors out there. Go on the internet, put in DSDs. There are probably 50 of them that’ll prop, uh, prop, uh, pop up for you. As a matter of fact, the last time I looked at it, which was like 2024, there were actually 50 active DSD sponsors out there. So, and big major, you know,
financial organization. So this isn’t your neighborhood guy with his latest deal. So ⁓ what happens is you take in the example I’ve been using of having the million dollars, you give that to the sponsor. The sponsor aggregates that and as an example ⁓ with let’s say 30 other people that are doing the same thing.
So now they have $30 million and the trust DST, the Delaware Statutory Trust goes and buy, let’s say a $60 million property, which is a 50 % LTV. And then they’re managing that for you. And so you basically have a fractional ownership and a prepackaged investment. You don’t have to go hunt something down.
And it’s institutional quality assets generally. And with all investments, none of them are 100 % guaranteed because there’s risk in every investment. But the point is
take the $30 million and let’s say they buy a $60 million property. In their operation, they’re paying off the $30 million loan. And then…
The trust exists for a period of years, depending on the management, maybe three, five, seven years, when the trust may flip the property. Let’s just take as an example, a five-year flip. Well, during the time that they’ve been paying you your, let’s say, five or 6 % on your million dollars every month, which at 6 % on a million would be somewhere around…
$5,000 a month, which is spendable. ⁓ then, ⁓ if they flip it in five years, they would have paid down their $30 million loan. Some, I don’t know how much, let’s just say $3 million. Well, that $3 million accrues to your benefit and
then the property probably inflated, which is why they’re selling it. Say it inflated to $70 million. So there’s a $13 million gain that gets shared back basically to you and your interest. And then you can roll that over into another DST, which is again, a tax deferrable deal or by the way, I have some DSTs so.
it’s experience not guessing, you can take part of the DST out, pay the tax on it, and put the rest back into another DST if there’s a change. So ⁓ one of the problems that happen if you don’t do a DST, if you’re trying to do a straight 1031 exchange is you’ve got very precise rules, and if you violate the rules, it’s like,
football game, you know, you get penalized. And so what those are, the basic rule is if you’re doing a straight 1031 exchange and a DST meets all these requirements, like kind property, 45 day identification and 130 day closing period. So you have time pressures, you got to find the suitable property and now you’re back into managing new property again, which is what I wanted to avoid.
So 1031 exchanges are great for retirees and professional busy, busy people are just, you know, going from active involvement into passive involvement. And there are big assets like apartment complexes, medical offices, distribution centers, even government buildings you own there. Some of the DSTs I have are actual
ownership of producing wells, not exploration, which is risky, but they know what the production is. So they’re producing and, so you own part of the production, which also gives you a depletion allowance tax credit. So there are different things that you can do that. They’re all pre-structured offerings. So, you know, you don’t have to go invent something. It’s there.
Debt’s already in place. You’re not personally liable on the debt. You get regular distribution and usually it’s a stabilized asset. ⁓ Some things about it is you don’t have to negotiate the loan. ⁓ That’s done for you. ⁓ You just don’t have a management problem there. ⁓ You also, it’s illiquid.
Now it’s not a stock that you can buy and sell. You, it’s not a market out there for that. I’ve always wanted to create a market, but you know, there are too many. It’s so difficult to do. ⁓ but, but you can sell them because there are people that will buy your interest. I’ve had offers on mine and, and, ⁓ so, but it’s not like a stock market. can’t easily sell the.
things, you’re also outside of the decision-making authority when you do that. so ⁓ that’s basically the outline of how DST works. And ⁓ from there on, you just educate yourself. And it isn’t like there are one or two of them around. think ⁓ I was talking with
one of the sponsors and he thought there were ⁓ over $80 billion in DSTs already existing. So it’s a significant amount. The other thing that we were talking about earlier is ⁓ I’m surprised that it’s not well known in the financial area.
Scott Bursey (21:00)
That is an excellent breakdown.
I am too. And I gotta ask you Ray, given your experience in high stakes litigation, what is the single biggest liability risk that you see real estate agents consistently underestimating in their daily operations?
Ray (21:29)
Well, it is such a complex area to talk about. They all have risk. Now, the greatest risk.
Well, from the standpoint of what we’re discussing here, the greatest risk is probably advising your client.
Not advising your client about a DST. The reason is, is because if you’re a somehow assisting him somehow in the transaction and he later finds out he could have saved 250,000 bucks, he’s going to look at you and say, why didn’t you help me in this transaction? And so people need to be educated on that because you know, you can’t offer something you don’t know anything
And if you’re holding yourself out as a
real estate professional, then perhaps you should know about the tools of a real estate professional.
Scott Bursey (22:31)
Absolutely, and I gotta ask you this as well. It’s been on my mind since we booked you, How should real estate professionals evaluate their current heirs and omissions policy to ensure that they are covered against major claims, especially considering the president set by large judgments like the one that you secured?
Ray (22:54)
Well, ⁓ you know, I was ⁓ one of the things that we didn’t talk about earlier was I do a lot of expert witness work or did. ⁓ And ⁓ the reason is, is because there’s always the coverage issues that come up ⁓ under facts of the policy.
Because if you could sell a policy that would cover everything, nobody could afford it. So every policy has conditions. These are the things we’ll insure. And then they have exclusions. We’re not going to insure this stuff. And ⁓ so that falls heavily into litigation. And so how do you… ⁓
How do you as a real estate ⁓ person, you know, protect yourself in that area? You have a good agent that explains it to you and you talk to him about your concerns and the risks. Because again, a policy can’t cover everything. so, ⁓ insurance is, you don’t buy it because… ⁓
you’ve liked it in that sense, you buy it because you can’t afford not to have it.
Scott Bursey (24:19)
Sure, understanding policy language is clear. Clearly, that’s something to gloss over,
Ray (24:30)
Well, when I was employed with the insurance company, they asked me to ⁓ make coverage decisions. And so I would write that. I recall I wrote in the space of, think, I don’t know, two or three years, whatever it was, I probably, I think I wrote 950 coverage opinions on what is covered and what isn’t covered on, you know, all kinds of
policies, liability to property coverage, because there’s a lot of risk on that stuff. And so that’s over in the insurance side of things. Here on the DSTs, we’re talking about protecting your, you know, being able to advise your client on high dollar investments and high dollar exposures.
Scott Bursey (25:27)
Absolutely. And Ray, I wish we had more time. We’ve covered a lot of ground here today. And I know people are going to want to tap into your brain. What is the best way for them to reach out?
Ray (25:42)
My email, ⁓ RaymondBJohnson@gmail.com. I have a website because I, as we discussed earlier, I published a number of books and you can find those books on Amazon. They’re actually on several different platforms, but Amazon’s the easiest under Raymond B. Johnson. ⁓ happy to talk to people. ⁓
done a lot of expert witness work over the years for 20 or 30 years, probably on coverage of insurance policies. ⁓ so I’m not very active anymore because I play too much pickleball and ⁓ ride my bikes and stuff. But the ⁓ point being, I’m happy to discuss it with people.
Scott Bursey (26:39)
We need to have you back on the show very soon. Thank you for joining us today,
Ray (26:46)
Happy to do so. Thank you.
Scott Bursey (26:49)
And for our listeners who see and appreciate the content here, if you kind of vibe or found some gems in this episode, do us a favor, hit the subscribe button. We’ve got a heavy lineup of guests, just like Ray coming your way in the near future. Until next time, keep your standards high and your vision clear. We’ll see you in the next episode, everyone.